The Crossword Centre Clue-Writing Competition

CCCWC January competition voters’ comments
 
Clue no. 51: Such a fuss was made of Vera lap dancing!

Back to competition result  |   All the comments  |   Other competitions

A clue to PALAVER.
2 comments refer to this clue (from 2 competitors, 0 others)
Move your mouse pointer over any bold clue number to see the clue.

Here is the text

 
Comments on the competition
1.
Clues 51 and 37 vied for equal maximum points – it was just the name Vera that won the day for me: the thought of the eponymous Giles character lap dancing proved irresistable!
2.
PALAVER was a friendly clue-word, offering numerous possibilities. This was reflected in the size of the entry, but it was disappointing that so few of the clues offered much originality or flair and that some of those that did were unsound. Many of the surfaces were rather feeble or even, in a few cases, perverse. “Rod” to indicate LAVER without any reference to tennis seems unsatisfactory to me: there are lots of other Rods, and it’s half a century since Laver was at his peak.

4 points each: 2 and 38 – two neat &lits, though “engage in” sails a bit close to the wind.

3 points: 18 – simple and economical.

1 point each:

15 – a clever idea quite skilfully executed, but rather too long.
37 – an excellent idea for the definition. A pity that the words chosen for their first letters weren’t a bit pithier and less vacuous – “long and very extensive”? Also, “starting” isn’t quite right as an indicator; some approach like “starts to pall…” would have been sounder. Much Ado would have been quite adequate, thereby shortening the clue to good effect.

0.5 point each

28 – “One who might arrange the flags…” would have been sounder

34

51 – the simplest and best of the lap-dancing clues.

61

Prox. ac.:

13 – sounder and/or less contorted than the other Carry On entries, but suffers from the fact that the film is imaginary.

20 – the surface of a promising comp. anag, spoiled by the inappropriate word “Convoluted”, which doesn’t suit the surface.

43 – quite neat wordplay, but the surface is unconvincing.