Comments on the clues |
---|
1. A top university, not for admitting the fellow that's one! |
1. | Nice idea and construction, but difficult to see this as pointing uniquely to 'oxhead' as an &lit | 2. | The best & lit. clue |
|
2. Alec hoaxed Hector (6) |
1. | This anagrind needs to be before the fodder | 2. | Not convinced with 'Hector' as anagrind unless it is in the imperative | 3. | Imperative anagrind following fodder doesn't work. Swap names round and the clue's fine. | 4. | Does the def. refer to 'smart Alec'? If so, not really a stupid person. |
|
3. Alexander’s horse brandished a neat crown |
1. | Surface doesn't make sense. Bucephalus definition needs translation indicator | 2. | The leap from 'brand' to 'brandish' is very tenuous | 3. | Too many obscure connections for my liking |
|
4. Alexander's horse was literally an ass |
1. | Bucephalus definition needs translation indicator | 2. | Simplest and best of the warhorses. |
|
6. Box the bad, initially discarded part of slaughtered cattle (6) |
1. | Surface not convincing at all, why box something that's bad and discarded? |
|
7. Bucephalus haunch a dolt |
1. | Surface makes little sense. "Bucephalus" overloaded and first def needs translation indicator | 2. | 2½ definitions maybe, using 'Bucephalus' twice |
|
8. By pursuing love with that man, lady's exposed as stupid |
1. | Shame about the "as" | 2. | "By pursuing love" for OX is excellent, but, to me, "that man" is HIM not HE, while "lady's exposed" for “omit outside letters” is a stretch |
|
9. Dean, maybe, having mislaid his car, is a numskull. |
1. | Rather indirect in both elements of wordplay. In any case, no Oxford college has a Dean as its head. |
|
10. Dope – excessive amount consumed by hospital drug academy |
1. | OD is the consumer not the consumed | 2. | Nearly v. good but 'hospital drug academy' is unconvincing in the surface |
|
11. Dope from old Times leader |
1. | Neat wordplay, jars a bit with definition. | 2. | Neatly constructed charade | 3. | Head is clued as head with the same meaning, Otherwise a nice clue |
|
12. Dope ring backed by union of Triads transporting ecstasy to the West (6) |
1. | Wordplay seems to lead to OEHXAD | 2. | How does X = ecstasy? |
|
13. Dotty hoaxed dolt |
1. | Hoaxed* was bound to be too common |
|
14. Dumbo and what's in box he adulterated |
1. | Surface not so great – it's the contents rather than the box that would be adulterated |
|
15. Easily hoaxed idiot |
1. | Easily spotted by others too! |
|
16. First off, Buffalo Bill strangles the man for dope (6) |
1. | The wordplay works but the surface doesn't |
|
18. Fool old man on a date stealing a kiss (6) |
1. | ‘Stealing’ means ‘removing’, ‘snatching’ might be better. |
|
19. Foolish ex had admitted love for an idiot |
1. | Tense of containment indicator ugly. | 2. | O should be in front – EXHAD* is not “around” O | 3. | The O is outside the anagram! |
|
21. Heads off to box the mad old dolt (6) |
1. | "To" isn't the right preposition in wordplay, it's "heads off from" | 2. | Don't see the need for archaic indicator. An alternative for 'heads' might have suited better to avoid something part of the entry itself |
|
22. Idiot box, headache essentially |
1. | 'essentially' to show hidden but not in the centre doesn't work so well | 2. | 'Essentially' is one of those indicator words that often spoils a good clue |
|
24. Idiot had taken a container without lid first (6) |
1. | The wordplay "<subject> taken a" has faulty grammar | 2. | Appears to lead to OXHAD |
|
25. I'm horny over ten hours each day |
1. | A different take, with some humour thrown in. But 'horny' isn't quite 'horned'. Some indication of cryptic definition may have helped | 2. | Nice surface and definition | 3. | Very good charade | 4. | My winner by miles | 5. | My stand-out winner – clever clue with simple construction, original and amusing. Bravo! |
|
26. In paradox, he, a donkey |
1. | The hidden wordplay/surface combo is great. I think the definition is very imprecise though | 2. | Nice find |
|
28. Incompetent neatness? |
1. | Need to indicate that 'neatness' must be split | 2. | Nice idea but baulked a bit at the oxymoron surface reading and the broadness of the def. |
|
29. Lower class symbol of cuckoldry |
1. | A cryptic def maybe but can't see this as an &lit |
|
30. 'Lummox', he admitted, encapsulates him |
1. | Nice hidden clue that would be improved by a ? |
|
31. Might he be easily hoaxed? |
1. | Hoaxed* too easily spotted to be unique |
|
33. Neatness exhibited by genius? Just the opposite! |
1. | Need to indicate that 'neatness' must be split |
|
34. No 10 has lost the initiative – the leader is a buffoon (6) |
1. | X interrupts the thing being chopped and its chopper. Great surface though. | 2. | I don't feel that 'initiative' works as a first letter indicator |
|
35. No kiss for Uncle Ned, Norman Watt-Roy or Chaz Jankel? |
1. | The definition is too indirect and synonyms aren't used irl for proper nouns | 2. | Blockhead = definition, yet does not appear in your clue. |
|
36. Noodle's some way from traditional soup. |
|
38. Numbskull Chief, not Sitting Bull |
1. | Very confusing. What is not sitting or being excluded? And how does head ox become oxhead? | 2. | How do you rearrange the components? What are you excluding with 'not Sitting'? |
|
39. O indicated by this in clue of wife's unfaithfulness? Ximenes would not approve! |
1. | I accept the wordplay with the warning but it's undisguised and not gelling with surface |
|
40. "O, kiss man!" – Alexander's dictate starts Bucephalus |
1. | I know Bucephalus translates as oxhead but you need to indicate that a translation is required |
|
42. Old idiot box without top lead |
1. | Can't see need for archaic indicator |
|
43. One could easily be hoaxed |
1. | Hoaxed* too easily spotted and replicated | 2. | Best of the simple anagram of hoaxed |
|
44. One's first ex had strayed |
1. | Very loose definition. It doesn't just happen to idiots! |
|
46. Ring ex had melted down, was really foolish. |
1. | Part of speech mismatch in definition. | 2. | Definition seems grammatically wrong? | 3. | Definition indicates wrong part of speech. |
|
47. Short of stock, brand leader's tip to draft worker |
1. | An original definition, but the deletion of O is very awkward |
|
48. Simple translation of Alexander’s. |
1. | Don't quite see how this works other than the 'simple' part | 2. | Probably pretty universally an unseen translation! Fiendish. | 3. | Three obscure connections make this unsolvable | 4. | Highly ingenious, but, though "horse" is an obscure synonym for "translation", I feel that, in the clue, too much is being asked of the word |
|
49. Slow van after level crossing |
1. | Not convinced that crossing = cross for X |
|
50. Steer needed before he'd get answer? |
1. | Doesn't read grammatically well for the containment part | 2. | "He'd getting/(gets?) answer" needed for the cryptic reading, which is of course nonsense. | 3. | Good definition, but not keen on ‘get’ as a containment indicator, and for the cryptic sense it needs ‘gets’ | 4. | "needed" is a cop-out |
|
51. Steer president towards Lyonnaise specialty. |
1. | Def a bit vague, and ox for calf is a bit of a stretch; 'towards' as link indicator also not very appropriate | 2. | This relies on a very obscure bit of knowledge |
|
53. "The inspiration for the first letter's in this box," he added |
1. | I am happy with the definition but "this" is extraneous in fodder |
|
54. The Minotaur was such an idiot |
1. | Minotaur has a body and tail as well? And the construction seems to suggest 'ox-headed' |
|
57. Twerp is neatness personified |
1. | Liked this the best among the 'neatness' clues | 2. | Need to indicate that 'neatness' must be split |
|
59. Upper part of lower hexad, properly arranged, needs nothing to introduce it |
1. | Not sure I understand the surface reading |
|
60. Where to go for neat dope (6) |
1. | Amusing charade, perhaps in need of a ? | 2. | Quirky but likeable idea – perhaps would be fairer with a ? but original and amusing. |
|