Comments on the clues |
---|
1. A foreign body entered intestine, causing a hostile reaction. |
1. | Nice idea for hiding OPAL but flawed as devilled version reads better than undevilled. |
|
2. A son e-hating them all is hot online |
1. | The devilled version is a bit too garbled. |
|
3. American tourists shot in Harrods |
1. | Nice surface reading for both versions. By far my favourite clue. |
|
4. Apply a layer of pastry to steak in the pie |
1. | Flawed as devilled version reads better than undevilled (also missing "to" in explanation). |
|
6. Big sidespin arsenal, right? Back Stan Smith for Wimbledon victory. |
1. | Both versions too convoluted for my liking. |
|
7. By beating to vine list A, Kramnik became undisputed World Chess Champion |
1. | Am I alone in not understanding the devilled version? |
|
10. Charlie Parker would make a cool bum. |
1. | The devilled version would need to be ‘cool b-bum’ |
|
11. Dramatist celebrity has died |
1. | The original is less fluent than the devilled version. |
|
12. EU backs tight Irish border control until UK trade deal reached |
1. | Topical, but a bit of a mouthful and really needs to have "is" in the undevilled version (which of course would mean OPAL wouldn't work) | 2. | Nice topical ref. |
|
13. Gallon: G |
1. | Nice idea but needs some context – e.g. "Many horses gallop along behind the truck" | 2. | Deserves a share of the points for originality and bravery. | 3. | The undevilled reading should be more of a sentence I think. |
|
17. I shot at coop to get chicken and eggs |
1. | Nicely misleading, but with a good hint of where the break is – by far the best clue | 2. | This is at the top of my pile because of the neat change in meaning and mild humour. | 3. | Good change of meaning. |
|
18. "I sup port" – glowing Kavanaugh in the High Court |
1. | Nicely topical, with a bonus pun in the devilled version. And surely 'port' doesn't need to be capitalised. |
|
19. In the corner she's good value, especially if you buy a crate |
1. | The devilled version has a slightly bizarre ring to it, which is OK. |
|
21. In the witch's shack of ginger-bread is unforgivable. |
1. | The devilled version can be offbeat, but should at least be grammatical. | 2. | The devilled version needs to make sense grammatically |
|
23. It's unseemly to rubbish lover in massage parlour |
1. | The bishop in the original is a bit arbitrary |
|
24. Just one cone in the street to stop people parking there. |
1. | Interesting | 2. | Good, but beaten to the points by 25 |
|
25. Many will curse a motorway idiot, but a traffic cone can stop him |
|
26. Many women shone despite being married |
1. | I like the slightly sexist sound of the devilled version |
|
28. Novel switch could charge hand-held in mid-air (4) |
1. | Neither version makes much sense, but the undevilled version is particularly unbelievable |
|
33. Rode in drome |
1. | I don't understand what the undevilled version is supposed to mean |
|
36. Stateroom reservation celebrating an October anniversary (4) |
1. | Despite having a definition (of sorts), the undevilled version doesn't really make sense. |
|
37. Steak with lots of dripping? It sounds really awful. |
1. | Slightly better than the other 'leak' clue. | 2. | Very good change of meaning |
|
39. That faded Matisse, it is almost colourless |
1. | This clue stands out as both the devilled and undefiled versions read so well |
|
40. The book's harm was scarcely perceptible. |
1. | I liked this clue. It would have been my next choice. |
|
45. Toxic gas released – intestine creates biohazard zone |
1. | This needs a bit more to justify ‘Palestine’ in the original |
|
48. Women shone happily for their husbands |
1. | Nice image, just beating 26 due to the amusing wording | 2. | Just beats 26 for humour |
|